Will & Eve said:What you are saying makes sense except for the problem that history doesn't reflect that analogy.
In fact, almost everything economically that's been proposed to help black Americans has in fact HURT them.
Economically speaking, African Americans were coming along smartly before the Great Depression and even in the fifties, outside of poor regions where EVERYONE was poor (the Mississippi delta for instance) blacks were prospering at roughly the same rate as whites (segregation notwithstanding)
Johnson's "war on poverty" has decemitaed the black family in America and is probably THE major factor in the remaining economic inequality.
Sociologists can debate WHY those policies disproportionately impacted blacks, but the stats prove it.
The bottom line I'm getting at is this - the disadvantage SOME blacks still have economically does NOT derive from slavery and it's aftermath.
Furthermore, the very fact that virtually ALL of the well-to-do black people in America reached their station after beginning in a relatively impoverished state reinforces the point that it's NOT the poverty you start in that prevents your success.
IF it were true that slavery, and racism after the war, started the black "runner" 200 yards behind, then how do we explain Oprah? Condi Rice? Herman Cain? Colin Powell? Barak Obama? Clarance Thomas? and a multitude of others?
Almost without exception they started in the same conditions of poverty that our poorest black neighbors experience today - what made the difference?
With the exception of education grants, in pretty much NONE of those cases did federal dollars and programs make the difference.
Where are these stats. from? Fantasy Island?
I'm sorry to be glib...but you couldn't be further from the truth.
The fact of the matter is that racism still affects us today...and yes the lingering effects of slavery are still around today.
Does this mean that black people can't overcome this and still achieve great things...HELL NO. Of course we can.
But to act as though it doesn't exist seems downright silly.