In the morning Sarah treated me like someone with a deadly disease. An awkward silence separated us. She continued to treat me like that until later in the afternoon when she seemed to slowly ease up a little.
"Last night was crazy," I finally said.
Sarah nodded, but didn't say anything.
I remembered her cries the night before. I touched her arm. "Did he hurt you?"
She shook her head. "No, he didn't hurt me," she said softly.
"So ... you liked it?"
She hesitated, started to say something then stopped. Finally she shrugged. "I don't know," she said, "It was different."
She looked at me. "Did you like it?"
I hesitated too, afraid to hurt her feelings. "Like you said, it was different," I finally said.
The truth was I really got off witnessing Shane ramming his cock into my wife. I thought of it all the time. What I enjoyed the most was the way he slowly seduced her, how he slowly won her over and, even if she was married, she gave in and offered her body to him. I constantly had a huge boner and relieved myself several times.
She said, “I was mad! What happened last night was a big mistake. Is anything wrong with both of us?”
I told her I did not feel bad about what happened.
"I will never do it again. We're married and it might mess us up so bad we may never be able to get back what we have now."
I told her she didn't have to be scared, she had nothing to worry. "Look, let's forget Shane today. How would you like to go to dinner at the hotel's restaurant and then dancing? I heard there's a new club some 15 minutes drive from here."
She said yes, then asked, "Just you and me, right? It's our date, just the two of us?"
I told her it would be just the two of us.
That night Sarah looked fantastic in an all black outfit gave her a sexy look. The dinner at the restaurant was very nice and we had a good time until I saw Shane walking into the place heading to the other side of the room. Sarah saw him too and whispered to me that she didn't want to see him tonight.
But Shane saw us and waved at Sarah. She waved back and then looked down again.
I teased her, saying, "I think he's looking real good tonight. What do you think?"
"David, I feel uncomfortable. I can't believe you are talking about this," Sarah responded irately.
"All right, please, just listen for a second. Wouldn't it be fun just to flirt a little? You wouldn't have to go all the way," I insisted.
"That is unless you want to try it more than once," I kidded, seeing her hesitation.
She said, "What if that really happened? Would you be OK with it?"
I thought about it and said, "That could happen sure. And if it did, I'm sure we could talk about it."
"Can't you see this could really hurt us, both of us?"
"It would be ok for one more time and then we could get back to our lives." I was almost begging when I finished saying that. We sat there for a short while, not finding any more to say.
Before long Shane walked over to our table. He said, "Hello Sarah, you look very beautiful. You always do but tonight you seem to be even more lovely."
Sarah told him thanks. Shane then suggested we go for a drink after dinner. I told them it was OK with me but Sarah immediately said, "That's nice but we already have something planned!"
Shane said, "Only one drink, Sarah! Come on."
"Well OK. One drink and then David and I, we'll go dancing, OK David? This night is for us, not anyone else."
"Agreed, one drink and then we go dancing, just the two of us!”
Shane offered to drive us all to the bar that was just outside the hotel. Sarah stopped me on my tracks and said, "I think it would be better if we took our own car. We're only having one drink then we're going dancing. You promised."
As the two of us walked outside to our car, Shane came running after us and said, "Well I'm having some trouble with my car, David, and if Sarah doesn't mind, we can go there in your car."
Sarah sighed and said, "Get in."
Fifteen minutes we reached the bar. I was surprised to see they had a band and there was dancing going on. I told Sarah, "They have a live band tonight. We can all dance here itself."
Sarah looked at me and said, "I was sure it would just be you and me. I mean isn't that what we talked about earlier?"
I said, "It's OK, Sarah."
Sarah said, "Well, I was sure tonight was our date night. I guess I was wrong."
She seemed pissed off but stayed calm as we went looking for a table. Shane did not accompany us and was chatting with a group at another table. Sarah turned to me and said, "What is this? Are you trying to set me up or something?"
I smiled and said, "Of course not … unless you want to be set up, Sarah."
She said, "David, I was hoping, truly hoping that you and I would have a great evening but you had to destroy it. You had to invite Shane to join us! It's like you're pushing me to him. Why are you doing this to me?"
I didn't answer. Sarah said, "Just when I think we are moving closer together, you do something dumb and wreck it."
"I only want you to be happy! I mean you wanted to dance and we're here so let's dance. What's the problem?"
"The problem is Shane is with us. And I'm sure before the end of the night he'll be hitting on me again. Is that what you want?”
"It's not what I want Sarah, it's what you want. We both know it. Look if you don't want to do it, we'll stop it now and tell him we're leaving."
I excused myself for the men's room. A few seconds later, Shane showed up at the urinal next to me. With his dick hosing out a heavy stream of piss, he said, "David, you've got a very intelligent, lovely looking woman. Sarah is such a sexy lady."
Curiously I had trouble getting started, somewhat intimidated by the presence of Shane near me. "Sarah is beautiful," I managed to say.
Shane pushed it a bit further as we walked out saying, "I'll have to ask her to dance."
I didn't say a thing and we returned to the table and ordered a round of drinks.
Sarah started out on a conversation with me, but Shane cut us short by saying, "David suggested I dance with you and make sure you have a terrific evening. What do you think about that, Sarah?"
Sarah looked anxious and uncertain. "I don't think it's a good idea.”
Shane smiled a large re-assuring smile. "Don't worry about that, I’m sure he won’t mind."
"Do I have a choice in this?" she tentatively asked, trying to keep the nervousness out of her voice.
"Are those new heels?" Shane asked, suddenly noticing Sarah's new shoes. "You're so kind, to wear them for me."
Sarah flushed. "You think so much of yourself," she said. "I bought them to wear for my husband."
Sarah finally said, "I want to go home."
I looked at her and asked, "With me?"
She said, "Of course with you. You're still my husband."
"Ok," I said rising from the table, "let me fix the bill and we leave."
"It's time for us to talk. You've been avoiding me," I heard Shane say as I moved away.
"No, I haven't," Sarah said unconvincingly.
I stopped on my tracks to see what was happen.
"Did you fantasize about me today?" Shane asked.
"What?"
"You heard me. Did you think about me while David fucked you? Did you fantasize about me while playing with yourself?" Shane reached over and placed his hand on Sarah's thigh.
Sarah almost jumped as she felt Shane's hand on her leg. "Please, take your hand away ..." she whispered, stifling a moan as Shane caressed her inner thigh.
"... please stop ..." Sarah pleaded as Shane's fingers trailed up her leg and disappeared under her dress.
"Stop!" Sarah gasped in an urgent whisper, covering Shane's hand with hers. "Please," Sarah begged.
Shane stopped but didn't pull his hand away. "I wonder if your husband is going to let me fuck you."
Sarah stared at Shane in horror. "You're crazy, David would never let you have me."
Shane smiled. "Are you sure?" he asked. "Are you sure he didn't already give you to me?"
"Never again," she insisted somewhat weakly, feeling less confident.
"You thought about me today, didn't you? You wore those new shoes for me?"
"No," Sarah said, repeating her earlier denial. "Not you. I wore them for my husband." Sarah abruptly pushed her chair back. "I ... ah ... I have to go to the ladies room," she said, hoping nobody would notice how flushed she looked.
"Sarah, you don't have to feel ashamed or guilty. You and I both know David wanted us to have sex. He wants us to have sex again."
"No, you're wrong. It was a mistake. I don't want it to happen again, and David doesn't either."
Shane laughed. "Sarah, you know that's not true. David wants us to fuck again. He told me when we were in the men's room."
Sarah looked disbelieving. "He did not."
"Are you really surprised? You know David's fantasies."
"I don't believe you," Sarah insisted, but her voice carried little confidence.
Shane sensed Sarah's indecision, and took a step closer. "Your husband wants me to fuck his pretty wife." Shane smiled knowingly, and then brushed his fingers against Sarah's soft cheek.
Sarah pulled her head back, away from Shane's hand.
"We've been as intimate as a man and woman can be."
Sarah reached up and pushed Shane's hand away. "That doesn't mean anything. It makes us two people who made a big mistake."
Shane grinned lecherously. "Big like what?"
"You think so much of yourself," Sarah scorned, but she couldn't prevent her voice from quivering.
"Admit it," Shane said, his lips almost touching Sarah's face. "You want it as much as me."
"No, I don't," Sarah insisted.
Shane saw the longing in Sarah's face and smiled. He abruptly pulled away and Sarah gasped in frustration.
"You can then go back to your husband," he said, a look of amusement on his face.