I never said Gibbs didn’t have talent. I merely said the talent he had to work with was not as good as Belechick’s. I don’t see how you can call his roster one of “no names” seeing as how he’s had Seymour, Bruschi, Harrison, McGinest, Coats, Bledsoe, Brady, Curtis Martin, Troy Brown, Cory Dillon, Branch and Seau just to name a few. Other than Monk, Riggins, Darrell Green, Manley and perhaps Wilbur Marshall and Joe Theismann, Gibb’s entire roster was one of “no names.” Even the fabled hogs were unknowns before being groomed into the best offensive line of all-time. Clark and Sanders were USFL players for Pete’s sake. Gibb’s system was considered genius when he took over in late 1980. His game-planning and intelligence in putting together an unprecedented staff (Bugel, Hannifan, Petibone) at the time was also key.
I’m not saying Belechick is not a good coach. He knows how to put a defense together. I’m merely saying that if he were the coaching God the media has created that he’d have had more success in Cleveland and more titles in New England. The media portrays him as such a coaching genius that it is a shock to them when he loses. If this were true, why does he ever lose? The smartest move (and one of the most telling about his character) was how he screwed the Jets. Had he gone there he’d not be a head coach in the NFL now but rather just another coordinator. He was smart enough (and unscrupulous enough) to know he couldn’t win there and jumped shipped for another opportunity which was much better and conducive to winning.
The Patriot’s organization has given him the pieces, year in and year out, to be a contender. I would say the ownership and front office are among the best in the league. That has been they key in the Patriot’s success more so than Belechick’s coaching ability. Or at least that’s my opinion. Granted the Redskins, back in the day, had an equally stellar owner and front office and that was a key for them also in the continuity of winning. For me to concede that Belechick is among the elite of all-time coaches, he’d have to build a team from scratch (like Gibbs did) and then coach them to the same heights. Until he does so he’s just a great defensive coordinator who lucked into an ideal situation and didn’t mismanage it. There’s only so much room on the Mount Rushmore of coaches and those spots are already taken by Walsh, Gibbs, Landry, Knoll and Shula. There are a few coaches trying to climb it and affix their likeness on the face of the mountain but they aren’t there yet. To get even close Belechick would still have to pass Ditka, Madden, Reeves, Parcells, Johnson, Cowher, Bud Grant, Dick Vermeil, Marv Levy and several others. At least in my mind.